KBS、MBC、SBS三家電視臺的歌謠大典都落下了帷幕，歌手們結束了一年的活動，在一周至一個月不等的練習後登上了2010年最後的舞臺。讓我們來回顧一下三家歌謠大典的優缺點。
SBS：華麗的舞臺，連續的事故
上下部收視率分別為：16.3%，14.5%
SBS於29日在日山國際展覽中心首先舉行了歌謠慶典，利用了多種特殊道具展開了大規模的華麗演出，前後輩之間也有默契配合，不僅是舞臺，播出的視頻影像也令人印象深刻。
但是表演途中麥克風雜音和攝像的問題不斷，特別是切斷了正在表演中的Tiger JK和Supreme Team的舞臺，因此受到了批評。
KBS：無誠意的導演，新老歌手和諧的舞臺
上下部收視率：14.5%，13.8%
30日在首爾汝矣島KBS大廳舉行的KBS歌謠大慶典，受到了“兩個小時長的音樂銀行”和“偶像特輯”的指責。很大規模的舞臺只有3、4隊演出，顯得空蕩蕩的。簡陋的燈光和佈景也讓歌手們的努力顯得寒酸。
抒情歌的皇帝申勝勳和CNBlue、SISTAR、IU、Super Junior等歌手演唱了“미소 속에 비친 그대”、“로미오와 줄리엣”、“I believe”、“처음 그 느낌처럼”。DJ Doc也和Super Junior、After School成員表演了“나 이런사람이야”和“Run to you”。
MBC：良好的構成，但是缺乏清晰的概念
上下部收視率：10.1%，9.3%
31日，最後的“歌謠大典”在MBC夢想中心舉行，因完成度很高的構成而得到了很高的評價。
表演經過了更有誠意的準備，比如Narsha、徐仁英、孫丹菲的熱門曲重編排，帝國的孩子們和Infinite的舞臺也預告了2011年的回歸。
CNBlue和FT Island展現了對前輩們的敬意，Super Junior和女生組合的90年代熱門曲回顧“GoGo90”也帶來了快樂。Victoria和Nichkhun的couple舞蹈，以及BoA的“Girls On Top”都值得一看。
但是無法區分歌手們的分組給整個演唱會的概念帶來了混亂。儘管主持人一直在邀請觀眾進行短信投票，但參與度並不高。由於兩個隊伍的對決缺乏緊張感，所有最後發表獲勝隊時並沒有像導演期待的那樣令人興奮。
概括Recap of the 2010 SBS, KBS, and MBC year-end gayo shows
Source: Daily News via Nate
http://news.nate.com/view/20110101n02953
by VITALSIGN on December 31, 2010
All three of the year-end ceremonies for KBS, MBC, and SBS. In celebration of the year’s end, dedicated artists gathered together to rehearse and practice for their performances for a month in advance, resulting in an impressive and spectacular week-long festival for fans to enjoy.
Daily News took the time to analyze the strengths and weaknesses of each show, as follows:
○ SBS: “Despite the impressive visuals, the show was a train of accidents.”
Part 1, 2 Rating – 16.3%, 14.5%
SBS aired their “Gayo Daejun” the first out of the three on December 29th at the Ilsan KINTEX. The large-scale ceremony was held in front of a 3,000 member audience.
The show itself featured a variety artists and performances for fans to enjoy, such as the use of wires and other special equipment for the maknae stage’s “Circus” performance, the collaborations between Kim Gun Mo and 2NE1, and Kim Jong Seo and F.T Island. Intro videos also showed the time and dedication put into perfecting the visual aspect of the show.
Unfortunately, the concert itself was plagued by noise from faulty mics and camera mishaps. Tiger JK and Supreme Team’s collaboration was also cut off mid-way in order to give way for advertisements, which brought out criticisms from viewers.
○ KBS: “Careless directing, and the harmonization of the old and the new.“
Part 1, 2 Rating – 14.5%, 13.8%
Held at the KBS Hall on December 30th, KBS’s “Music Festival” earned the criticisms of many for being a ‘two-hour long Music Bank‘ and an ‘idol special.’ The concert itself was too large of a scale when it was only housing three to four teams, making it look empty and deserted. The sloppy lighting and backgrounds also made the hard-work of artists look shabby as well.
Thankfully, the special performances that focused on the theme of harmony was worth a watch. Yang Hee Eun and Supreme Team meshed well despite the difference in their genres.
The emperor of ballads, Shin Seung Hoon, CNBLUE, SISTAR, IU, Super Junior and others collaborated to perform “Your Reflection In My Smile,” “Romeo & Juliet,” “I Believe,” and “Like the First Time.” DJ DOC also performed “I’m This Kind of Person” along with “Run to You” with the members of Super Junior and After School.
○ MBC: “Charming and cute composition, but lack of a clear concept.”
Part 1, 2 Rating – 10.1%, 9.3%
The last of the three, MBC’s “Gayo Daejun” was held on December 31st at MBC’s Dream Center. It featured charming and cute composition in comparison to the former two, and earned high remarks for its level of perfection from the directing department.
Performances were also well planned, such as the sexy diva competition between Narsha, Seo In Young, and Son Dambi, and miss A’s stunning re-arrangement of their hit tracks. ZE:A and INFINITE’s performances did well in hyping their comeback for 2011.
CNBLUE and F.T Island’s performance perfectly displayed their respect towards their seniors, and the division of Super Junior as DJs and girl groups into 90s hit tracks doubled the joy. Victoria and Nichkhun’s couple dance, and BoA’s ending performance were also well worth a watch.
Unfortunately, the inability to differentiate between which groups were a part of the blue and white teams brought confusion to the overall concept of the show. MCs constantly asked for text votes throughout the show as well, despite the participation remaining low.
Because of the lack of tension in the competition aspect between the two teams, the declaration of the final winning team was not as exciting as directors probably hoped.
全站熱搜
留言列表
